πŸ“ˆ ETF Trader

4 strategies paper trading side by side Β· updated Mon Nov 16, 8:35 PM ET
Fake money Β· no real trades

In plain words

After 1 trading day, the leader is S&P 500 + trend filter at $9,994.06 (βˆ’0.06%). None of the robots is ahead of just holding the S&P 500 ($9,994.06) yet. It's very early. Small differences now are mostly fees and day-to-day noise. Judge the robots after 2–3 months, and on how they handle a bad month. Robots trade once a month; on other days they just hold and check.

Leaderboard

1
S&P 500 + trend filter
$9,994
Return βˆ’0.06%vs S&P hold 0.00% Worst drop -0.1%Trades 1
2
Do nothing: hold S&P 500
$9,994
Return βˆ’0.06% Worst drop -0.1%Trades 1 Β· yardstick
3
Momentum top 2, 12-month
$9,993
Return βˆ’0.07%vs S&P hold βˆ’0.01% Worst drop -0.1%Trades 2
4
Half S&P 500 + half momentum
$9,993
Return βˆ’0.07%vs S&P hold βˆ’0.01% Worst drop -0.1%Trades 2

Account values

$9,953 $9,975 $9,997 $10,018 $10,040 start Nov 16 Nov 26 Dec 06 Dec 16
S&P 500 + trend filterDo nothing: hold S&P 500Momentum top 2, 12-monthHalf S&P 500 + half momentum

Dashed grey line = the yardstick (just hold the S&P 500). Lines above it are winning.

Each account

S&P 500 + trend filter $9,994

Holds the US top-500 fund while it's rising; moves everything to bonds while it's falling. Trades only a few times a year.

Cash $110.26Fees $1.00 Last reshuffle 2026-11Started 2026-11-16
FundSharesValueAvg costGain
ZSP.TO85$9,884$116.340.0%

ZSP = Top 500 US companies

  • 2026-11-16: Bought 85 ZSP.TO @ $116.34
Do nothing: hold S&P 500 $9,994

Bought the US top-500 fund once and never touches it. This is the yardstick: a robot is only worth it if it beats this, or matches it with smaller drops.

Cash $110.26Fees $1.00 Last reshuffle 2026Started 2026-11-16
FundSharesValueAvg costGain
ZSP.TO85$9,884$116.340.0%

ZSP = Top 500 US companies

  • 2026-11-16: Bought 85 ZSP.TO @ $116.34
Momentum top 2, 12-month $9,993

Holds the 2 funds that rose most over the past year, as long as they're still rising. Anything that isn't goes to bonds. Smallest drops in testing.

Cash $141.31Fees $2.00 Last reshuffle 2026-11Started 2026-11-16
FundSharesValueAvg costGain
XIU.TO92$4,968$54.030.0%
ZSP.TO42$4,884$116.340.0%

XIU = Top 60 Canadian companies Β· ZSP = Top 500 US companies

  • 2026-11-16: Bought 92 XIU.TO @ $54.03
  • 2026-11-16: Bought 42 ZSP.TO @ $116.34
Half S&P 500 + half momentum $9,993

Half the money always sits in the US top-500 fund. The other half holds the 2 funds that rose most over the past year β€” if they're still rising β€” otherwise bonds.

Cash $67.12Fees $2.00 Last reshuffle 2026-11Started 2026-11-16
FundSharesValueAvg costGain
XIU.TO46$2,484$54.030.0%
ZSP.TO64$7,442$116.340.0%

XIU = Top 60 Canadian companies Β· ZSP = Top 500 US companies

  • 2026-11-16: Bought 64 ZSP.TO @ $116.34
  • 2026-11-16: Bought 46 XIU.TO @ $54.03

πŸ§ͺ Strategy lab

17 strategies replayed on real prices since 2014, plus older data that includes the 2008 crash. Ranked on growth and safety; re-runs on the 1st of each month.

1
Half S&P 500 + half momentum
Growth/yr 13.1%Worst fall -21% In 2008 βˆ’23%
2
Momentum top 2, 12-month only
Growth/yr 10.8%Worst fall -18% In 2008 βˆ’7%
3
US S&P 500 + trend filter
Growth/yr 11.4%Worst fall -24% In 2008 +6%
4
Do nothing: US S&P 500
Growth/yr 15.5%Worst fall -27% In 2008 βˆ’37%
5
Momentum top 2 + trend filter (original bot)
Growth/yr 9.7%Worst fall -18% In 2008 βˆ’7%
6
Momentum top 3 + trend filter
Growth/yr 9.2%Worst fall -19% In 2008 βˆ’5%

Past results never guarantee future ones. Testing many strategies also finds lucky ones, which is why the robots paper trade first.

πŸ“– What these words mean

Four robots each pretend to invest $10,000 with a different strategy. Once a month the three active ones decide what to own; the fourth just holds the US stock market and is the yardstick. This page updates every weekday after the close.

Value
What the account is worth now: cash + funds at the latest prices.
Return
Value compared to the starting $10,000. A minus sign means it's down.
vs S&P hold
⭐ The most important number. How far ahead (+) or behind (βˆ’) of simply holding the S&P 500 fund. A robot that stays behind for months, without having smaller drops, isn't worth running.
Worst drop
The biggest fall from the account's best point so far: how painful the ride has been. At βˆ’20% a robot's safety switch stops it trading.
Trades
How many buys and sells it made. Each costs a $1 fee, so fewer is better.
Rebalance
The once-a-month reshuffle on the last trading day of the month. In between, robots just hold.
ETF / fund
One "share" that holds hundreds of companies.
Avg cost / Gain
The average price paid per unit, and how much that holding is up or down since buying.
Slippage
Real trades fill slightly worse than the quoted price; the robots include this small cost.
Kill switch
The safety brake. If losses hit the limit, that robot stops and waits for you.
🏷️ The funds
XIU
Top 60 Canadian companies
ZSP
Top 500 US companies
XEF
Big companies in Europe, Japan, Australia
XEM
Emerging countries (China, India, Brazil…)
XBB
Canadian bonds: the safe place